Who on Who

Awikiforum project: http://gclub.ourproject.org/awikiforum/
ATK= Analysis Toolkit from "Knowledge Forum" (propietary soft)

• Who's read who?
• Who's coauthored with whom?
• Who's built on whom?
• Who's annotated whom?
• Who'r referenced whom?
• Who's link to whom?

This between 2 users or between 2 groups

What is the difference between built on and annotated?
I think "built on" means like posting after other's post, while annotated would be like commented with reference to the previous post. xavi

I would suggest some things (added mu name at the end). Hopefully other people from the awikiforum project will add their comments, if they differ xavi.

• to know who reads who
  • wiki page viewed / page creator (last page editor?).
    there should be a field like "main editor", or "editor in chief", or "head of all the writing to this wiki page" (I can't find adequate English Words: "Cap de redacció", "Jefe de redacción"...). This is not necessarily the first author (which could be the teacher in some cases), nor the last editor. And this could be more than one person (thus: multiple select box). xavi
  • message viewed ? / message author
    yes. xavi

• forum viewed / thread creator (last thread editor?)
  no last thread editor, but all of thread posters at the moment of the view xavi

• to know who coauthors
  • wiki page updated / page creator + all page editors
  • comment updated
  • forum updated

• to know who replies to who
  • comment posted / page creator (last page editor?)
    just to the "editor/s in chief" of the commented page. xavi
  • comment replied / comment creator (last comment editor?)
    comment creator that is replied (since comments can be replied at different levels, then the initiator of the level which is being replied to). xavi
  • forum posted / thread author (last thread editor?)
    thread author and previous specific post which is being replied in the thread xavi
    I don't understand your question: "last thread editor?". Does my comment answer your question? xavi
  • forum replied / post author (last post editor?)
    post author and I would suggest to include "thread's author" xavi
    I don't understand your question: "last post editor?" Does my comment answer your question? xavi
  • message replied ? / message author
    I don't understand your question: "message replied?" xavi

• to know who references to who
  There should be an optional textarea below the post to allow saving urls of others students' posts/pages, in a similar way as the Blogs work ("ping traqckback"). But hopefully, this should be an option for all types on activities concerned (wiki, forum, blog, message)

In Tikwiki 1.10, all these actions are already logged
Do we need to collect image view and file view and blogs view/replies?

• I'd suggest not in the first page. In a second phase probably yes. xavi

In most of the case, we must define if we consider the last editor or the creator of the objects.

• depends on each situation, I think., I commented each case. xavi

The results will be displayed as 2 tables users/users . One table for reads, and one table for replied. Each cell will contains the number of actions that occured from user a to user b.

Tikiwiki is missing the notion of object. We can't use a join to find all the second author of an action
question
- do we use a join for each type of object to retrieve the second user
- do we save in actionlog this second user

the group who will be gnerated from the user who table

• ???? xavi